Forum vs Facebook

Want to talk about classic motorboats, recent and forthcoming CMBA events or your latest escapades? This is the place to do it!

Moderators: Alacrity, Rapier

Post Reply
User avatar
solitaire
Posts: 1021
Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2009 4:02 am
CMBA Member: 511
Location: Cheselbourne - Nr Dorchester

Forum vs Facebook

Post by solitaire »

It would appear the CMBA face book page is getting a great deal more use for passing on information about events and useful info than the Forum these days.
I expect I am not alone in noticing the Forum is becoming very quiet vs Facebook. Is Facebook the way to go if the a Forum is dying.u

kwoffa
Posts: 120
Joined: Wed Nov 01, 2017 1:09 pm
CMBA Member: 1180
Location: surrey

Re: Forum vs Facebook

Post by kwoffa »

I think that's the way a lot of Forums have/are going
I m a member on several other Forums (car related) and they have gone that way too,personly i find this Forum very quiet and almost outdated,i have often read a post only to find it's years out of date,i also do not understand the Clubhouse,you are either putting info out there or not..postng is restricted to non members I think Forums are great and are required as lots of older members do not have or want a Facebook page ! However they do need to be used and kept up to date a job people find a bit of a chore...please keep the forum running.. it just needs a moderator to give members a nudge that we are still here.. Mel.

User avatar
welshhealey
Posts: 267
Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2009 2:14 am
CMBA Member: 71

Re: Forum vs Facebook

Post by welshhealey »

Well said Mel, just to reiterate, not a lot of “senior folk” have a “Facebook “ account, and don’t particularly want one, I myself don’t have one for various reasons, plus a lot of my colleagues likewise ! so keep the forum alive, we need it !

User avatar
Rapier
Site Admin
Posts: 13892
Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2009 5:16 pm
CMBA Member: 569
Location: West Glos

Re: Forum vs Facebook

Post by Rapier »

I enjoy both the FB page and the forum (which has been running successfully for over 10 years..). Both sites do cover different subjects and the FB page appeals to a newer generation - see also Fletcher owners and various nordic boating FB pages.. . As a member of the AOMCI (paid), John Old Mercs (paid) and Fiberglassics (free)forums - I see they all have a vast number of members who contribute - some daily, with help, comment and advice. In the US, both antique / classic boats and motors can be bought for very little outlay and the 'hobby' is both cheap and rewarding so that expertise is always in demand - with my knowledge now I tend to use all 3 forums for the questions that can't be asked here. There's less demand in the UK and a different social dynamic to posting, plus many topics have been debated to death, so it is what it is really...

The only other comment I'd make is there's a core of people who continue to support the forum, from those who trawl through and delete the dozens of spammers every day, administer the site and others who post items for sale, comment, advise and organise and post events, for no pay or material reward, other than to encourage people to enjoy what the CMBA is about. This isn't evident to many, but is why we all need to use it, or lose it...
Fasten bra straps and remove dentures...

User avatar
solitaire
Posts: 1021
Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2009 4:02 am
CMBA Member: 511
Location: Cheselbourne - Nr Dorchester

Re: Forum vs Facebook

Post by solitaire »

Thanks everyone - I am would also hate to see the Forum die, there always appear to be plenty of people viewing but just not much input - must be the time of year! - also agree the search facility is often overlooked as a valuable source of data on a host subjects that has been discussed in the past.

Like a few other members, I,m not signed up to Facebook but anyone can view the public pages - https://www.facebook.com/groups/145124038858927/ - some links to lovely boats.

Woodwych
Posts: 177
Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2012 6:05 pm
CMBA Member: 0

Re: Forum vs Facebook

Post by Woodwych »

I've found the forum invaluable as a source of advice and support- it would be a shame if it didn't survive. The old posts are a great resource and sometimes provide the only info on certain boats or techniques available on the internet. Facebook is OK but it just seems too superficial and transient to explore anything properly.
There is a very definite winter lull on the forum as projects and activities slow down with the winter weather but thats just how it is.
Must just thank those in the background for their hard work in keeping it running. And of course Rapier for the ebay links!

User avatar
Alacrity
Site Admin
Posts: 2193
Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2009 2:07 pm
CMBA Member: 641
Location: Eastbourne, South East England
Contact:

Re: Forum vs Facebook

Post by Alacrity »

I too hope it survives, we lost a lot of subscribers a couple of years back when we had issues with our hosting people. The forum became virtually unusable to to slow speed issues, sadly many folk have not returned since we changed hosts.
Mercs are like women, no 2 are exactly alike. That's what testing is about. In general it is safer to test motors and props than women!

kgarla
Posts: 105
Joined: Wed Jul 20, 2011 3:02 pm
CMBA Member: 143

Re: Forum vs Facebook

Post by kgarla »

Personally I believe they are two separate entities both with advantages over each other. I see no reason why both cannot be put to good use to further the CMBA and help both members and non members alike. Thank you to all persons who contribute to both formats. Cheers Kgarla

Post Reply